Wall Street Journal review of 'Why We Drive' by Matthew Crawford

The coronavirus has parked multitudes on their sofas, where many have gone half-mad reading rants from advanced-studies graduates of the University of ­Twitter. Matthew Crawford’s “Why We Drive” is the perfect antidote. 

Mr. Crawford, a senior fellow at the University of Virginia and the author of “Shop Class as Soulcraft” (2009) and other works of social philosophy, has written a thoughtful, entertaining and substantive work about the joys of driving—and about the attempts by various scolds to relegate that joy, and similar expressions of independence, to the junkyard of history. 

Driving, Mr. Crawford explains, can be a daring undertaking that provides the pleasures of “being actively and skillfully with a reality that pushes back against us”—­sometimes harshly. Driving is a “domain of skill, freedom, and individual responsibility.” To drive “is to exercise one’s skill at being free.” Or, as an earlier philosopher might have put it: I drive, therefore I am. 

Mr. Crawford is not spouting theory—he is a practitioner. During one 12- month stretch his motorcycle driving passion ­resulted in four emergency-room pit stops. He has caused police jaws to drop as he passed through radar traps just slightly below the speed of light. Yet real road ­danger, he says, comes courtesy of the two-headed monster ­created by technological progress and safety neurosis. This is a monster with teeth. 

Highway deaths, he writes, rose at their fastest rate in 50 years between 2013 and 2015. Why? Because “cars became boring to drive. . . . I mean really boring. . . . Driving a modern car is a bit like returning to the womb.” Drivers are increasingly insulated from the road; self-braking devices, navigation screens, cruise control and similar gizmos result in less ­attentive drivers. Smartphones, which promised to keep “boredom at bay,” keep eyes off the road, to disastrous effect. 

Meanwhile safety monitors keep their pitiless vigil. Their purpose, Mr. Crawford suggests, is less risk reduction than good old-fashioned pillage. In 2016, he says, “the District of Columbia took in $107.2 million from its photo radar traffic enforcement cameras.” The cameras were strategically placed in intersections heavily used by commuters from Virginia and Maryland and harvested what amounted to “free money,” in Mr. Crawford’s analysis. Chicago raked in $600 million from red-light cameras, augmenting the take by shortening yellow-light duration, a move that itself caused a jump in rear-end crashes and injuries. In the same spirit, lowering speed limits to unrealistic levels means more manna for localities and for insurance companies, which, after certain traffic violations, can extract higher premiums for years. 

The chapter titles in “Why We Drive” reveal an instinctive skepticism and pleasant pugnaciousness: “The Diminishing Returns of Idiot-Proofing as a Design Principle,” “Auto­mation as Moral Reeducation,” “ ‘Reckless Driving’: Rules, Reasonableness, and the Flavor of Authority.” Among much else, he takes up old cars (he’s their friend); road rage (a rejection of egalitarianism that is aided by tinted windows); and the DMV (visiting which offers a “civic education in submission to a type of authority that relies on unintelligibility to insulate itself”). 

He can be evangelical at times, as when attempting to convince a rural Virginia judge that motorcycling 30 mph or so over the speed limit shouldn’t necessarily be considered reckless. When you’re “riding a bike you are not texting, not looking at your navigation screen, not fussing with the kids in the backseat,” he explained during a court appearance. Plus, you have “a lot of skin in the game”—since you’ll leave lots of it on the road if you crash. His argument didn’t find much traction with the judge but was a noble effort. 

Mr. Crawford is at his best rattling the smug beliefs of “bicycle moralists, electric scooter gliders-about, and ­carbon teatotalers,” not to mention safety nags, whose ­mission in life is to pour their enlightened sugar into renegade gas tanks. While he recognizes that people who invoke safety “enjoy a nearly non-rebuttable presumption of ­public spiritedness,” he thinks that an abundance of caution diminishes us. A fixation on risk reduction, he explains, “tends to create a society based on an unrealistically low view of human capacities.” In contrast to the U.S., ­Germany—which has no speed limit on some roads—“treats citizens like adults. This is a bracing concept.” 

Mr. Crawford, who admires the adage “Every Man Dies. Not Every Man Lives," visits pockets of resistance, including a demolition derby animated by a love of mayhem for its own sake; it recalls, he says, an “Iron Maiden concert, circa 1983.” At a “Hare Scramble” motorcycle race, women ride like demons and berate their men to "man up. ” In France, 60% of automated radar devices had been disabled as of January 2019, likely the work of the Yellow Vest movement. 

Yet the resistance is not winning. “Qualities once prized, such as spiritedness and a capacity for independent ­judgment, are starting to appear dysfunctional.” A Kant quotation (the author quotes only the finest) sums up the enlightened view of resisters: “We look with profound ­contempt upon the way in which savages cling to their ­lawless freedom.” 

Silicon Valley will take it from here. Its plan is fairly ­simple: “removing us from the driver’s seat.” Some will benefit more than others, Mr. Crawford says. Rides in self-driving cars “will remain cheap only until the buses and trains disappear. Then the laws of monopoly pricing will take effect.” Surveillance capitalism, meanwhile, will empty passenger pockets with nearly supernatural virtuosity, “nudging” us to buy stuff by sending self-driving cars ­toward the types of businesses that show up in our digital conversations. “It seems likely there will be real time ­auctions to determine the route your Google car takes,” Mr. Crawford explains, “so you can be offered empowering choices along the way.” Suddenly, being parked on the sofa doesn’t seem so bad. 

Mr. Shiflett’s writing and original music are posted at Daveshiflett.com

16 comments

  • Liza
    Liza United States
    I CAME ON YOU BLOG AND I HAVE READ YOUR BLOG POST IN WHICH YOU SHARED WITH US ABOUT "WALL STREET JOURNAL REVIEW OF 'WHY WE DRIVE' BY MATTHEW CRAWFORD" I am really enjoying your article while reading. And, I also shared with you something that All most all peoples think that which VPN is safe for online streaming such as Netflix and other online streams. That [url=https://boundbuzz.com/is-hola-vpn-safe-for-netflix/]Hola VPN Safe for Netflix[/url] does insure to everyone uses Netflix whenever you want. It is reliable and sufficient for users.

    I CAME ON YOU BLOG AND I HAVE READ YOUR BLOG POST IN WHICH YOU SHARED WITH US ABOUT "WALL STREET JOURNAL REVIEW OF 'WHY WE DRIVE' BY MATTHEW CRAWFORD" I am really enjoying your article while reading. And, I also shared with you something that All most all peoples think that which VPN is safe for online streaming such as Netflix and other online streams. That Hola VPN Safe for Netflix does insure to everyone uses Netflix whenever you want. It is reliable and sufficient for users.

  • asewe
    asewe Austria
    [url=https://normalizegreatness.com/]positive quotes[/url]
  • Urielle Hart
    Urielle Hart south africa
    Ladies never again were the faltering purchaser yet a bread worker for the family. An ever [url=https://www.global-lover.com/]lover dresses online[/url] increasing number of ladies begin acquiring great as industrial facilities began employing them since they were more focused laborers contrast with men.

    Ladies never again were the faltering purchaser yet a bread worker for the family. An ever lover dresses online increasing number of ladies begin acquiring great as industrial facilities began employing them since they were more focused laborers contrast with men.

  • Alexa Stanley
    Alexa Stanley canada
    On the getting side: Most Internet fax merchants will furnish you with a telephone number that you would then be [url=https://topfax.net/]topfax[/url] able to provide for your clients.

    On the getting side: Most Internet fax merchants will furnish you with a telephone number that you would then be
    topfax able to provide for your clients.

  • nyloky kmar
    nyloky kmar Australia
    Manage union: an international organization that offers certification [url=https://teebyslater.dk/]teebyslater[/url] services for a selection of programs--such as many organic certification programs.

    Manage union: an international organization that offers certification teebyslater services for a selection of programs--such as many organic certification programs.

  • Felicia Parsons
    Felicia Parsons Austria
    We are now into the twenty-first century, and the t-blouse remains as famous [url=https://supermerch.dk/]supermerch[/url] as ever. T-shirts of yesteryear have been not anything just like the t-shirts you already know today.

    We are now into the twenty-first century, and the t-blouse remains as famous supermerch as ever. T-shirts of yesteryear have been not anything just like the t-shirts you already know today.

  • Malia Wilson
    Malia Wilson America
    Awesome blog. Have you been aware of the Minecraft game and do you want to add shaders to our game? Then try ‘Not Enough Items mod’ on your game once. This mod is not only great for players who desire to learn about survival experience but also for those who like to goof around in some amazingly creative ways. https://gitlab.com/m2113/learn-gitlab-ultimate-trial/-/issues/16

    Awesome blog. Have you been aware of the Minecraft game and do you want to add shaders to our game? Then try ‘Not Enough Items mod’ on your game once. This mod is not only great for players who desire to learn about survival experience but also for those who like to goof around in some amazingly creative ways. https://gitlab.com/m2113/learn-gitlab-ultimate-trial/-/issues/16

  • Evan Mills
    Evan Mills Deleniti beatae iure
    They previously held solid business associations with the buggy makers that turned into the [url=http://karpelnero.com/]karpelnero[/url] principal vehicle organizations. They additionally utilized gifted skilled workers who might have turned their endeavors to making cowhide seat covers or different parts of the vehicle.

    They previously held solid business associations with the buggy makers that turned into the karpelnero principal vehicle organizations. They additionally utilized gifted skilled workers who might have turned their endeavors to making cowhide seat covers or different parts of the vehicle.

  • Kaye Forbes
    Kaye Forbes Vero officia volupta
    Wisconsin Dells in Wisconsin is frequently alluded to as the "Water Park Capital of the [url=https://wildrivers.com/]wildrivers.com[/url] World" and all things considered. With 18 indoor waterparks, it effectively has the most indoor water parks of any state in the US.

    Wisconsin Dells in Wisconsin is frequently alluded to as the "Water Park Capital of the wildrivers.com World" and all things considered. With 18 indoor waterparks, it effectively has the most indoor water parks of any state in the US.

  • Mariam Hardin
    Mariam Hardin Enim earum facilis s
    All things considered, we'll simply give you the most compelling motivation, which is that it makes [url=https://ultimatephotobooths.com/]ultimatephotobooths[/url] your work significantly simpler. Occasion photography programming will computerize the method involved with overseeing and naming photographs, and will even assistance you when it comes time to alter the photographs.

    All things considered, we'll simply give you the most compelling motivation, which is that it makes ultimatephotobooths your work significantly simpler. Occasion photography programming will computerize the method involved with overseeing and naming photographs, and will even assistance you when it comes time to alter the photographs.

  • john
    john United States
    Hello, this is very useful material. This article is really inspiring me to do the same thing as you.. If you want to get a [url=https://turkey-e-visa.com/turkey-tourist-visa/]Tourist visa to Turkey[/url], you can fill out the Turkish eVisa application form in minutes, and then you are allowed to enter Turkey legally.

    Hello, this is very useful material. This article is really inspiring me to do the same thing as you.. If you want to get a Tourist visa to Turkey, you can fill out the Turkish eVisa application form in minutes, and then you are allowed to enter Turkey legally.

  • Sherry Mefford
    Sherry Mefford New York, NY
    I always enjoyed reading your all your articles. That's why I never get tired following your site till now. [b][url=https://hq.monkeyknifefight.com/]dfs picks[/url][/b]

    I always enjoyed reading your all your articles. That's why I never get tired following your site till now. dfs picks

  • Albina
    Albina USA
    [url=https://www.evernote.com/shard/s381/sh/3885ab84-d18f-72ed-9baa-edb286b73adf/3204a3cb094d7db3706fcc0b1d12dcc8]likes for followers instagram[/url]
  • Albina
    Albina USA
    [url=https://www.kwa.org.kw/forum/general-discussions/best-vipleague-alternative]buy american instagram followers[/url]
  • Damon Cabrera
    Damon Cabrera Leupp, AZ
    Thank you very much for the great help by sharing this informative and inspiring post. I realize this is an old post, but it was insightful nonetheless. [url=https://libidodrops.com]libido booster for females[/url]

    Thank you very much for the great help by sharing this informative and inspiring post. I realize this is an old post, but it was insightful nonetheless. libido booster for females

  • Travis Wilson
    Travis Wilson Southfield, MI
    [url=https://ketoshoppinglisthq.com/]Keto coffee drinks[/url] I learned lots of useful information every time I visited you post. I can't express how much I appreciate your great work. But thank you for the generosity and keep them coming!

    Keto coffee drinks I learned lots of useful information every time I visited you post. I can't express how much I appreciate your great work. But thank you for the generosity and keep them coming!

Add comment